Automated Valves - Are They Worth It?
Posted: Thu Dec 10, 2015 12:55 pm
I've recently found the ECC forum while researching the BCS controller for my planned brewery upgrade. There's a wealth of helpful info here along with the HBT forums.
I'm designing a new system. I intend to use the BCS462 controller for an all electric system assuming I can run a 50amp service. One area I am looking at is automating valves (both 2 way and 3 way) like the ones offered by Johnson Controls. Given the added cost, slow response, and BCS interface making throttling flows a trial and error process, I'm wondering if it's even worth pursuing. I like the idea of being able to automate certain processes so I can "kick back" or multi-task more on brew day, but in reality my OCD tendencies means I'll likely be standing guard anyway.
I should add that through my business I already source valves from Johnson Control. I'm not so concerned about cost as I am practicality of undertaking the added complexities associated with incorporating automation into the system. So wondering if there is a real benefit to justify the added effort.
The intended system will be a 4 vessel design: HLT, HEX, MLT, and BK. I plan to fabricate the HEX at my business and will be using it to step mash and also as a chiller with iced water coming from HLT. So several different flow paths from each vessel.
Anyone have any experience upgrading from manual to automated valves and care to share your thoughts?
Anyone dive head first into the automated valves never to look back with no regrets?
Thanks in advance.
I'm designing a new system. I intend to use the BCS462 controller for an all electric system assuming I can run a 50amp service. One area I am looking at is automating valves (both 2 way and 3 way) like the ones offered by Johnson Controls. Given the added cost, slow response, and BCS interface making throttling flows a trial and error process, I'm wondering if it's even worth pursuing. I like the idea of being able to automate certain processes so I can "kick back" or multi-task more on brew day, but in reality my OCD tendencies means I'll likely be standing guard anyway.
I should add that through my business I already source valves from Johnson Control. I'm not so concerned about cost as I am practicality of undertaking the added complexities associated with incorporating automation into the system. So wondering if there is a real benefit to justify the added effort.
The intended system will be a 4 vessel design: HLT, HEX, MLT, and BK. I plan to fabricate the HEX at my business and will be using it to step mash and also as a chiller with iced water coming from HLT. So several different flow paths from each vessel.
Anyone have any experience upgrading from manual to automated valves and care to share your thoughts?
Anyone dive head first into the automated valves never to look back with no regrets?
Thanks in advance.